Davis, DeAndra. All the Noise at Once. Atheneum, 2025. 978-1-665-95265-1. $19.99, 373 p. Grades 9-12.
Aiden Wright is a black, autistic high school junior who wants to be on the football team just like his star quarterback brother, Brandon, and play with him before he leaves for college. Despite an overstimulation meltdown during tryouts, Aiden makes the team when a spot unexpectedly opens up. His acceptance onto the team is mixed due to some of the challenges he faces, and when one of his teammates picks a fight after their first game the police are called. When Brandon rushes to Aiden’s aid he is arrested and falsely accused of assaulting a police officer. As Brandon’s trial gets closer, Aiden and his new friend, Isabella, must try to figure out what really happened that night and find a way to prove Brandon’s innocence. Told in first person narration from Aiden’s point of view, the story skillfully describes what life can be like for a person with autism and also masterfully explores issues related to racism, social justice, and police brutality.
THOUGHTS: It was surprising to learn that this is DeAndra Davis’s debut book because it is so well done – she has written a fantastic story that is extremely powerful as she addresses difficult topics related to racism and police brutality as well as what it means to be Black and autistic. The relationship between Brandon and Aiden is extremely well developed, and the love they have for each other is sincere and a wonderful example of brotherhood. This is a must read for many reasons.
Realistic Fiction
Brothers, Brandon and Aiden Wright, share the same passion for football. Star quarterback and team captain of his Florida high school football team, Brandon enters his senior year striving to be the perfect son and the perfect protector of his younger brother, who is on the autism spectrum. Brandon is keen to have Aiden play football with him, but touch and noise send Aiden into a tailspin during summer tryouts. Despite this incident, the coaches accept Aiden on the team after one running back is injured and another moves away. After the team’s first winning game, a fight breaks out at their post-game celebration when one of the white team members pushes Aidan. Someone calls the police, the Black boys wind up in handcuffs, and Brandon is arrested for assaulting a police officer. As the weeks pass since the incident, Brandon’s future grows bleaker even though his well-organized mother’s law firm has taken the case. In the ensuing chapters, Aiden and his new friend from his Life Skills class, Isabella, try to prove Brandon’s innocence. Through Aiden’s narrative, the reader is privy to how he perceives his world, his reactions to navigating school sans Brandon, and his growing understanding of the ramifications of being a Black autistic male in today’s society. As the trial date looms, Aiden and Isabella stumble upon a key piece of evidence, a video of the police brutality, but the girl who possesses it cares more for her own skin than for Brandon’s welfare. In fluid, compelling prose, author DeAndra Davis shows readers how racism can penetrate even the most comfortable, careful Black families. Joining the canon of such titles as The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas, Invisible Son by Kim Johnson, and All American Boys by Jason Reynolds and Brendan Kiely, All the Noise at Once offers a unique perspective on how it feels to be a young, Black male who is autistic. The author’s ability to craft that voice so authentically while simultaneously providing a suspenseful plot makes this book a necessary read and an essential purchase.
THOUGHTS: Though the protagonists are of high school age, this novel will be an essential read for middle school students who are on the autistic spectrum. The play-by-play football scenarios will interest the sports-minded, while the heartfelt logic of the rational Aiden provides recognition to some and revelation to others.
Realistic Fiction