Lowry, Lois. Tree. Table. Book. Clarion Books, 2024. 978-0-063-29950-4. 194 p. $18.99. Grades 5-8.
Two Sophias. They both love tea. They both have strong opinions. They both love each other. However, one Sophia is in elementary school and the other is not. The book starts with the older Sophia forgetting that she left the kettle on and struggling with other memory things. The younger Sophia decides to help her out when she overhears that elder Sophia’s son is thinking of putting her in a nursing home. The reader will follow as Sophia tries to help her best friend with the help of her neighbors and friends more her own age, Ralphie and Oliver. By trying to help her friend, Sophia will hear stories of the past that she never knew and learn things about her friend that she didn’t expect.
THOUGHTS: This was amazing! I wish there were more flashbacks because I would have read 100 more pages about Sophia’s life before we meet her on page 1. Overall highly recommended for any elementary or middle grade collection.
Realistic Fiction
Eleven-year-old Sophie Winslow’s best friend is her next door neighbor, eighty-eight year old Sophie Gershowitz. They make up games together and share stories; despite the age gap, the younger Sophie relates more closely to the older Sophie than she does to fellow sixth grader, Ralphie, or autistic Oliver, her two other pals. When the precocious girl overhears her parents talking about Sophie’s worsening condition and the impending arrival of her accountant son, Aaron, she commits herself to making sure her best friend stays in her home. To help her in her project Ralphie gives her an old Merck Manual, a cast off from his father, a doctor, and Sophie looks up the guide for checking one’s cognition. She believes if she can prepare Sophie Gershowitz to answer the questions correctly, she can keep her in New Hampshire with her instead of having the older woman’s son take her to Ohio. As young Sophie narrates her daily steps in trying to get the elder Sophie up to snuff, the reader learns that memory is a fragile but powerful thing. A Polish immigrant, Sophie Gershowitz connects far-flung memories with the words her young friend suggests. Though the older woman’s short term memory is failing, certain words trigger deep and vibrant past memories. Urged by the words Sophie introduces, Sophie Gershowitz recalls scenes from her childhood in Poland: her memory of a favorite tree; the peril the Nazis brought to her Jewish family; and her deliverance into hiding. Even though she tries her best, young Sophie cannot prevent the inevitable. The older Sophie burns the kettle, can’t recall what they did that afternoon, and uses tricks to tell what day it is, so her son decides she needs special assistance closer to him. Much of this story is relating the pair’s close relationship and the young girl’s methodical and driven efforts to train her older friend so she can outsmart the cognitive tests. However, the underlying message here is that those with memory loss can still bring us joy and can still connect deeply with those around them. In true Lowry style, this book is written with tenderness and restraint and appeals to the sensitive reader
THOUGHTS: Other books like The Pictures of Hollis Woods, by Patricia Reilly Giff; Merci Suarez Changes Gears by Meg Medina; and Ruby, Lost and Found, by Christina Li have that same intergenerational theme that brings home the impact dementia has on those close to them and how their disability still warrants they be treated with dignity. Tree.Table.Book has a protagonist who understands what is happening to her older friend and is quietly raging against it, which may be not as relatable to the average middle school reader.
One weird turn in an otherwise thoughtful and well-written book is the over-explanation of Ralphie’s large family attributed to his Catholic religion.
Realistic Fiction
Meet the Sophies: Sophie G is in middle school and Sophie W is 80. Yep, 80! Despite their age differences, they are best friends. Sophie W’s son is coming to visit, and Sophie G overhears her parents talking about why. Lately Sophie W is having some memory lapses, and her son is suggesting she move home with him to a memory care facility. Sophie G will have none of it. Borrowing a medical text that has a memory test in it, Sophie G decides to prep her dear friend for her upcoming doctor visit. Sophie W does fine on some parts of the test, but when it comes to remembering certain words, she fails miserably. Sophie W comes up with a plan. She will have Sophie W tell a story about each word to help her remember them. Her memories are deeply personal, some she has never shared with anyone else! Even though this exercise is unsuccessful, the two friends become closer than ever after revealing these personal memories.
THOUGHTS: Wow! A little slow at first, once Sophie W starts telling her stories, this book becomes unputdownable! Our 5th grade reads Number the Stars by Lowry, and this would be a great read aloud to partner with that story. Filled with stories of war, loss, and hope this book will stick with you for a long time!
Realistic Fiction