Messner, Kate. The Trouble with Heroes. Bloomsbury, 2025. 978-1-547-61639-8. 288 p.$17.99. Grades 6-8.
In The Trouble with Heroes, prolific author Kate Messner peels off the different layers of Finn Connelly’s story. Told in verse form, the reader first meets the rising seventh grader as he receives his failing reports in physical education and English. Because his teachers know that Finn has been going through some tough times emotionally, they are giving him an extension over the summer months. To add to his troubles, he vandalized the local cemetery. One of the tombstones he damaged belonged to a local woman known for her rock climbing skills. In lieu of legal action, the woman’s daughter challenges Finn to climb each of the mountains in the 46 Adirondack High Peaks of their small upstate New York town with the help of the mountain climbing club. Since the pandemic, Finn and his mother moved in with his grandmother who runs the family candy shop. Finn goes from resisting the climbs to conversing with his companion climbers. We gradually learn that Finn is grieving his father’s death. Finn’s father was a firefighter who saved a survivor of 9/11. During the lockdown, his father stayed behind in Manhattan to care for the sick as a paramedic. Finn’s childhood has been punctuated by his father’s bouts with alcoholism and depression. Finn has lots on his mind and lots of issues to work out. To add to these problems, with thinning COVID crowds, his grandmother’s shop is failing. Finn has a flair for baking cookies (recipes included in the book) and finds a way to save the business. There is a lot of sadness to deal with in this novel but a lot of hope. Finn learns he can lean on others, express himself in his writing, and be proud of his dad who loved him.
THOUGHTS: This book will be published in April. Kate Messner is usually a safe bet for middle grade readers. This entry is a slow starter, but gradually the events in Finn’s life reveal themselves. There is a lot going on here: failed classes, moving to a small town, trouble with the law, baking, failing business, 9/11, COVID, death, alcoholism, and hiking. It can get confusing; it can also get interesting and very touching.
Realistic Fiction
“Local Cemetery Vandalized” is the title of an article in the Adirondack Daily News that opens the book The Trouble with Heroes. If Finn hadn’t been wearing his dad’s NYFD hat, he wouldn’t have been caught; he doesn’t always make the best decisions. Finn just finished seventh grade, but he didn’t pass. He needs to finish his ELA and PE assignments over the summer, and his ELA teacher wants him to write poems about heroes. His dad was a hero who saved people on September 11, but Finn isn’t ready to write about him. Because Finn vandalized the headstone of local mountain climber Edna Grace Thomas, he also needs to climb the 46 Adirondack High Peaks — with her dog. It’s better than paying for the headstone because the chocolate shop his mom and grandma run hasn’t been doing great lately. It’s going to be a difficult summer for Finn: climbing mountains with seasoned climbers; finishing his assignments; and dealing with a random, drooling dog.
THOUGHTS: Many books that claim to be written in verse are just prose presented in a choppy way. The Trouble with Heroes is beautiful poetry. ELA teachers could plan lessons around this book. Finn is a likable character with amusing observations who occasionally makes bad decisions. Students and teachers will love this book. I know I do.
Realistic Fiction